Approaches to causation in the social and natural sciences and their implications for theory building in sustainability science
Today’s global problems are complex. Disentangling their causes is difficult as they result from the interplay of social and ecological processes across multiple scales. A plurality of notions of causation exist in the natural and social sciences, however, their application to interdisciplinary fields
such as sustainability science has created debate and confusion. The purpose of the research environment is to bring together causal thinking in the social and natural sciences to 1) clarify different notions, their relationships and compatibility, 2) assess disciplinary approaches in terms of their ability to capture the complex and social-ecological nature of the problems, and 3) develop integrated approaches to causal analysis for sustainability science.
First, we will compare causal concepts and approaches across relevant fields. Second, we will assess how each approach can be used to understand environmental phenomena in selected cases. Finally, our insights will be synthesized into an integrated approach and process for theory
development. The research will combine multiple methods including philosophical explication, empirical analysis, network and agent-based modelling in an iterative way to develop and test thinking about complex causal processes. The research environment brings together fields that
rarely intersect to build a foundation for deeper understanding of socio-ecological problems and their governance. These include social-ecological systems research, complex adaptive systems, process philosophy, philosophy of physics, philosophy of social science, analytical sociology and theoretical ecology. The project is a collaboration between Stockholm Resilience Centre (SRC) at Stockholm University, the Institute of Analytical Sociology (IAS) at Linköping University, the Department of Theoretical Philosophy at Uppsala University and the Helmholtz Centre for Environmental Research, Leipzig-Halle (UFZ) in Germany.
Keywords: Causation| complex adaptive systems | social-ecological interdependence
People: Maja Schlüter (SRC), Tilman Hertz (SRC), Maria Mancilla Garcia (SRC), Emilie Lindkvist (SRC), Sonja Radosavljevic (SRC), Karl Wennberg (IAS), Petri Ylikoski (IAS), Carl Nordlund (IAS), Lars-Göran Johansson (Uppsala University), Volker Grimm (UFZ)
Methods: philosophical analysis, empirical analysis, network analysis, agent-based modelling, dynamical systems modeling
Funding: Swedish National Science Foundation (VR), grant for an interdisciplinary research environment
Sonja Radosavljevic, Thomas Banitz, Volker Grimm, Lars-Göran Johansson, Emilie Lindkvist, Maja Schlüter, Petri Ylikoski. (2023). Dynamical systems modeling for structural understanding of social-ecological systems: a primer. Ecological Complexity. Volume 56, 101052, doi.org/10.1016/j.ecocom.2023.101052
Thomas Banitz, Maja Schlüter, Lars-Göran Johansson, Emilie Lindkvist, Rodrigo Martínez-Peña, Sonja Radosavljevic, Petri Ylikoski, Volker Grimm (2022). Model-derived causal explanations are inherently constrained by hidden assumptions and context: The example of Baltic cod dynamics. Environmental Modelling and Software. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envsoft.2022.105489
Thomas Banitz, Tilman Hertz, Lars-Göran Johansson, Emilie Lindkvist, Rodrigo Martínez-Peña, Sonja Radosavljevic, Maja Schlüter, Karl Wennberg, Petri Ylikoski, Volker Grimm. (2022). Visualization of causation in social-ecological systems. Ecology and Society. https://doi.org/10.5751/ES-13030-270131
Emilie Lindkvist, Kara E. Pellowe, Steven M. Alexander, Elizabeth Drury O’Neill, Elena M. Finkbeiner, Alfredo Girón-Nava, Blanca González-Mon, Andrew F. Johnson, Jeremy Pittman, Caroline Schill, Nanda Wijermans, Örjan Bodin, Stefan Gelcich, Marion Glaser. (2022). Untangling social-ecological interactions: A methods portfolio approach to tackling contemporary sustainability problems in fisheries. Fish and Fisheries. https://doi.org/10.1111/faf.12678
Tilman Hertz and Maria Mancilla Garcia. (2021). The Cod and the Cut: Intra-active Intuitions. Frontiers in Sociology. https://doi.org/10.3389/fsoc.2021.724751